We created a monster. Every waking moment, E had to have her “me-me,” as she calls it. Her binky. Sometimes she had to have one in her mouth and another in her hand as a backup. If E didn’t have her binky, all hell would break loose until we put in that damn little plastic cork.
E turns 18 months old tomorrow. DH and I agreed that we’d wean her off of the binky during the day at 18 months, but we’d let her have it for naps and bedtime until she’s 2. It sounds easy enough, until E asks for her me-me and you tell her no and she morphs into a grizzly bear right before your eyes.
We started off slowly about a week and a half ago. I’d take it from her and hide it, and no matter how much she asked for it or how awful of a tantrum she threw, I would make her go a certain amount of time before giving it back. At first it was ten minutes, and as that got easier I increased it to 20. If she screamed or cried, we distracted her to the best of our ability. It didn’t always work; initially we spent up to ten minutes at a time watching E thrash around on the floor in a fit of tears, muttering “me-me” over and over AND OVER. Over the course of a couple days, she fussed less and less over it and about three days in, she went from 1 PM until her bedtime at 8 without asking for it even once.
Will we be binky-free (in the daytime) at 18 months? Yes. Was it a pain in the ass getting there? YES. Was it worth it? YESYESYESYESOHMYGODYES. Let me tell you why.
In 1.5 weeks, E’s top front teeth have become visible when she smiles–for the first time, ever. E’s vocabulary and language skills have improved noticeably since she no longer has a binky in her mouth all the time. Her annunciation is significantly better, she’s saying new words at a rapid rate, and she’s starting to string words together. E is also in a better mood overall. Before, she was so attached to her binky that if she didn’t have it, her world fell apart very easily. Now that she’s no longer reliant on it, her mood seems to be much lighter and relaxed. All of this has happened in just over ONE WEEK without the binky.
E does still get her binky at naptime and bedtime. And she knows it, too. When I start to get her ready for bed, she asks for me-me (a little more calmly than she used to), and she does get it then. But she does know when she wakes up the binky goes away, and even though she still gives it a shot and asks for it just once (little stinker), she is able to go about her day without a tantrum when I tell her the binky is going away until bedtime.
Did anyone else dread the inevitable binky-weaning? What were your strategies?